Guayusa vs yerba mate: two hollies, two very different cups
Guayusa and yerba mate are caffeinated cousins from South America with very different flavours and rituals. Here is how they compare, and why Peak Hype is made with guayusa.

A Saturday afternoon in a London park, and a group of friends from Buenos Aires are passing round a gourd with a silver straw poking out of it. That is yerba mate, and its cousin from the Amazon is quietly having a moment of its own.
Guayusa vs yerba mate comes down to two caffeinated hollies from South America with very different personalities. Yerba mate is bold, grassy and a little bitter, while guayusa is smooth, mellow and gently sweet, which is why we chose it for every can of Peak Hype.
The quick version
- Both are leaves from the holly family, and both contain natural caffeine.
- Yerba mate comes from the forests of Paraguay, Argentina, Uruguay and southern Brazil.
- Guayusa grows in the upper Amazon, mostly in Ecuador.
- Mate tastes grassy and punchy, and guayusa tastes earthy, rounded and soft.
- Peak Hype gets all of its caffeine from guayusa, served cold and lightly sparkling.
What is the difference between guayusa and yerba mate?
Think of them as siblings raised in different cities. They share a family, a social streak and a natural lift, but the flavour and culture around each cup are very different.
Yerba mate is the leaf of Ilex paraguariensis, and in parts of South America it is less a drink than a way of life. Guayusa is Ilex guayusa, a rainforest tree that Kichwa families in Ecuador have brewed at dawn for generations. If you want the full story of that leaf, our guide to what guayusa is goes deep.
How do people drink yerba mate and guayusa?
Both drinks are built around sharing, which is half the reason people fall for them. With mate, one person takes the role of the cebador. They fill the gourd with leaves, pour hot water over them and pass it round the circle, and everyone drinks through a metal straw called a bombilla before handing it back for a refill.
In Paraguay the summer version is tereré, made with ice cold water and fresh herbs. It means so much there that UNESCO added the tereré tradition to its intangible heritage list in 2020.
Guayusa has its own ritual, the guayusa upina. Families rise before the sun, brew a big pot over an open fire, share their dreams from the night before and plan the day together. One drink belongs to the long afternoon hang, and the other belongs to the early start.
Which tastes better, guayusa or yerba mate?
That depends on your palate, but they could hardly be more different. Mate is grassy, vegetal and a touch bitter, and some styles are dried over wood smoke, which adds a campfire edge.
Guayusa sits at the other end of the scale. It is naturally low in tannins, the compounds behind that dry, puckered feeling from stewed tea, so it stays smooth and slightly sweet even when it brews for a while. If you want a lift without an acquired taste, guayusa is the easy way in.
Does guayusa or yerba mate have more caffeine?
Both can match a cup of coffee when brewed strong, and both can be gentle when brewed light. With loose leaf, the amount you use and how long you steep it make the difference.
That is one reason we like guayusa in a can. Every Hype has the same 60mg of natural caffeine, so you know exactly what you are getting. For a wider look at how plant caffeine compares, read is all caffeine the same?
Why is guayusa catching up with mate?
Mate has had a head start in Europe for years, from Berlin bars to backpacks on long haul trips. Guayusa only became widely available after the EU approved it as a novel food in 2017, and it is now turning up on tea shelves, in cocktail bars and in the cans of people who care about where their lift comes from.
It suits the way a lot of us drink now: a real story, a flavour to look forward to and a lift that works for a run club morning or a long night in the studio. For more ideas, see our pick of the best coffee alternatives in the UK.
Meet Peak Hype
Our founder Louie swapped coffee for guayusa in 2020 and has had it every day since. He had noticed how many of us live in a loop of coffee to get going and alcohol to switch off, and that daily habit became the starting point for Peak.
Hype is our lifted mood: lifted, not wired. It is a lightly sparkling berry citrus drink with 60mg of natural caffeine from guayusa, 250mg of L-tyrosine and vitamins B3, B6, B7 and B12, which contribute to normal psychological function. It is vegan and low in sugar, sweetened with agave and stevia, with 28 calories a can. Hype contains caffeine and is not recommended for children or for women who are pregnant or breastfeeding.
Try Peak Hype, the guayusa mood drink in berry citrus.
Common questions
Are guayusa and yerba mate related?
Yes. They are both South American hollies, and they are two of only a handful of holly species that contain caffeine.
Is guayusa less bitter than yerba mate?
Generally, yes. Guayusa is low in tannins, so it tastes smoother and sweeter than most mate.
Can you drink guayusa cold?
Absolutely. It brews well over ice, and Peak Hype serves it cold with a light sparkle.
Where does Peak's guayusa come from?
Our extract comes from guayusa leaves grown in the Ecuadorian Amazon.
How do I try both moods?
The Starter Pack has 4 Hype and 4 Calm for £16, and UK delivery is free over £35.
Pick your mood
Lifted, not wired
CaffeineHow to beat the afternoon slump without another coffeeThe afternoon slump lands for almost everyone between one and four o'clock. Here is why it happens, the resets people swear by, and how a three o'clock ritual with Peak...
Mood drinksDrinks for creative work: from the studio to the deskEvery creative day has its moods. Here are the best drinks for creative work, from the blank page to the final mix, and the rituals that go with them.
Alcohol-freeWhat to drink before and after run clubRun club is the new night out. Here is what to drink before and after a run, from the warm up to the post-run ritual, and where Peak fits in.

